What Kinds of Stars Form Rocky Planets?

As astronomers continue to find more and more planets around stars beyond our own Sun, they are trying to discover patterns and features that indicate what types of planets are likely to form around different kinds of stars. This will hopefully inform and make more efficient the ongoing planet hunting process, and also help us better understand our own Solar System’s formation.

When a star is young, it is surrounded by a rotating disk of gas and dust, from which its planets form. As such, it’s expected that chemical composition of the star should in some way affect the compositions of the planets orbiting it. Indeed, previous research has demonstrated that gas giant planets preferentially form around iron-rich stars. But more recent results have started to suggest that smaller planets do not require such high iron content in their stars to form.

New work from a team including Johanna Teske, Origins fellow at DTM and The Observatories, extended this idea by measuring a large suite of elements besides iron. They found that stars with Earth-sized rocky planets are overall chemically similar to those with Neptune-sized planets, and to stars with no planets, but not to stars with gas giant planets.

The team examined the abundance of 19 different elements found in seven stars that are orbited by at least one Earth-like rocky planet, all discovered by NASA’s Kepler mission. Their work shows that small rocky planets like Earth do not preferentially form around stars rich in metallic elements such as iron and silicon. The result is surprising because iron and silicon are among the most abundant elements in rocky planets.

Their findings are published by The Astrophysical Journal.

“There has been much ongoing debate about the stellar conditions necessary for planet formation,” said lead author Simon Schuler of the University of Tampa. “Our results support the theory that the formation of small, rocky planets can occur around stars with diverse elemental compositions.”

“This means that small, rocky planets may be even more commonplace than we previously thought,” Teske added.

The planetary-formation from the gas-and-dust disk surrounding a new star as described above has also raised the question of whether the process itself depletes stars of the elements that are concentrated in the planets. If so, this could be used to improve our planet-searching abilities, as looking specifically for stars that show signs of this kind of chemical depletion could narrow the hunt. However, none of the seven stars the team studied displayed this suggested depletion signature.

“Finding small planets can be challenging, so it’s a little disappointing that we don’t have a clear pointer for finding their host stars,” Teske said. She works with Carnegie’s Paul Butler on one of the longest-running radial velocity planet searches, in which they are trying to find Earth-like planets. “However, at the same time our results are really exciting because they mean that small planets are very common and chemically diverse.”

Teske is presenting today at the Extreme Solar Systems III meeting, co-organized by the American Astronomical Society and Northwestern University’s Center for Interdisciplinary Exploration and Research in Astronomy (CIERA).

Top Image Caption: An artist's conception of Kepler-62f, a super-Earth-sized planet that orbits a star smaller and cooler than the sun, located about 1,200 light-years from Earth in the constellation Lyra. The small shining object seen to the right of Kepler-62f is Kepler-62e, which is roughly 60 percent larger than Earth. Image credit: NASA Ames/JPL-Caltech/Tim Pyle)

______________________________________

This work was supported in part by a grant and by telescope time from NASA.

Some data were obtained at the W.M. Keck observatory, which is supported by the W.M. Keck foundation. Additional data were obtained at Kitt Peak National Observatory, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy under cooperative agreement with the National Science Foundation. The research made use of the NASA Exoplanet Archive, which is operated by Caltech under contract with NASA.